Between the Ranger XL with the extended cab and 6 foot bed and 4WD, and the Maverick base model AWD. Kind of a difficult choice...the Ranger does offer a rear locker in all trim levels, but haven't had any need for one in any vehicle I've had...but I have a couple of trailers if I want to haul longer bulkier items than what would fit in the Maverick's bed....I don't really venture too far offroad, so the Maverick would most likely do what I'd want, but there are times where a quick trip to the box store without needing to drag a trailer along, the Ranger would be a better choice. The Ranger has a bit more towing capability, but I still don't think I'd want to try and pull my car trailer/tractor behind it, seems like the weight would really push the Ranger around...the Maverick isn't up to the task for towing the trailer alone would take up a bit more than 1/2 the capacity.
I guess more so it comes down to how short do you want your truck bed LOL. I was watching a video the other day on the Maverick. They took it up into some backroad testing stuff, I think it did pretty well considering its just AWD with open differentials...they did swap out the tires for some new BFG all terrain tires and it did even better...I was honestly surprised how the AWD system handled it. Maybe the Maverick would be enough, I just worry if we get another bad winter of a couple feet of snow, I don't think the Maverick would handle it, honestly don't think my 2008 Explorer would either, I'd have to go back to my 88 Bronco 2 LOL...but for the most part I think a Maverick might be in my somewhat distant future. I've seen a couple on the road now and they honestly don't look too bad for what they are. I'm sure with a different tire choice it'll do most of what many buyers would want them to do.
I think I'll stray away from the Ridgeline...I went and drove one yesterday, wasn't all that impressed....it handled fine but I don't think if I hooked up a trailer it would have the power to do it, I live down in a valley so any direction I go to get out there's quite a climb to do so, a loaded Ridgeline with a trailer in tow I think would be a constant struggle. My 2008 Explorer with the V8 handles the task fine, but at some point I'm going to have to look into something new(er) so maybe a Maverick as a daily and find a newer F150 or F250 to handle my hauling and towing needs when the time comes.